Starting August, we will release a biweekly newsletter, rounding up what's happening in tech and Internet in Global South, why it matters and what you or we can do about it. We'll post about opportunities to collaborate or participate in policy consultations. If you're interested, sign up to join the waitlist.
Submission: White House Office of Science and Technology Policy on National AI Priorities
Community Member
Community Member
Founder and Executive Director
The Biden-Harris Administration is developing a National Artificial Intelligence (AI) Strategy that will chart a path for the United States to harness the benefits and mitigate the risks of AI. This strategy will build on the actions that the U.S. Government has already taken to responsibly advance the development and use of AI. In June 2023, the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy (OSTP) requested public comments to inform this strategy on updating U.S. national priorities and future actions on AI.
Tech Global Institute members and advisors, Shahzeb Mahmood, Sabhanaz Rashid Diya, Sheikh Waheed Baksh, Abdullah Hasan Safir and Theodora Skeadas, submitted comments to OSTP in July 2023, mentioning considerations in the governance of AI, and the role of U.S. to accelerate international cooperation for ethical, inclusive and responsible AI. Specifically, we stress the impact of AI on low- and middle-income countries (“Global Majority”) and propose necessary safeguards to ensure the benefits of AI are equitable with design and governance as essential levers. We outline key takeaways below. The full comments are available here.
AI governance initiatives branded as “AI ethics” or “responsible AI” are based on the philosophical discipline of ethics. However, ethics is a malleable concept lacking universally agreed normative foundation, indivisibility, and enforceability inherent in human rights standards. International human rights laws are grounded in a well-calibrated approach that considers the legality, necessity, and proportionality of rights limitations, as well as an ecosystem for provision of redress for the public in case of violations, thereby offer a predictable, progressive, and potent benchmark for AI governance.
We recommend companies share externally information on data governance (to increase algorithmic transparency), bias and individual harm mitigation, societal concerns and dangerous capability monitoring. Information shared should be independently audited and updated at a regular frequency.
Common Crawler (used for most AI systems) uses only textual languages on the internet, which is predominantly in English. AI development should therefore be evaluated not only on the fairness of the technical systems, but also the environments in which it is developed, the diversity of the AI development team and their responsive to languages and multi-linguality.
The AI industry is built on the manual and repetitive data labeling and moderation tasks performed by low-skilled, low-wage workers in Global Majority regions, whose collective “ghost work” market value is estimated to reach $13.7 billion by 2030. There is an urgent need for international cooperation to establish labor protections for low-wage workers similar to parallel efforts in the readymade garments and manufacturing industries.
Before implementing AI-driven projects at scale, particularly outside of the U.S., it should be mandatory for companies to undertake and publicly share impact and fairness assessments, including inviting comments from stakeholders. This is important because AI systems can have disproportionate negative impacts on underserved communities, specifically among ethnic, sexual and religious minorities, as well as low- and- middle-income countries. Post-hoc fixes are unlikely to be effective against deeply rooted biases.
Community Member
Abdullah Safir is an AI ethics and critical design researcher and MPhil candidate at the University of Cambridge.
Community Member
Founder and Executive Director
Sabhanaz Rashid Diya is the founding board director at Tech Global Institute and Senior Fellow at Centre for International Governance Innovation.
Related Resources
Research
Research
Announcements